The crossword puzzle clue ""I'm not surprised"" has 20 known solutions in our database. Featured most recently in the Universal Crossword puzzle on October 5, 2022, the highest-ranked answer is ITFIGURES (9 letters) with 99% confidence. We compile solutions from major crossword publications to ensure accuracy.
Answer For "I'm not surprised":
Tap each ? to reveal a letter, or show all at once.
20 Other Potential Answers
Rank
Answer
Length
Source
Date
99%
ITFIGURES
"I'm not surprised"
(9)
Universal Crossword
Oct 5, 2022
99%
ITFIGURES
"I'm not surprised"
Universal Crossword · Oct 5, 2022
50%
USEDTO
No longer surprised by
(6)
LA Times Daily Crossword
Jul 7, 2026
50%
USEDTO
No longer surprised by
LA Times Daily Crossword · Jul 7, 2026
50%
GASP
[I'm surprised!]
(4)
LA Times Daily Crossword
Mar 27, 2026
50%
GASP
[I'm surprised!]
LA Times Daily Crossword · Mar 27, 2026
50%
HOLYMACKEREL
What a surprised fisherman might say!
(12)
Universal Crossword
Jan 20, 2026
50%
HOLYMACKEREL
What a surprised fisherman might say!
Universal Crossword · Jan 20, 2026
50%
IMSPEECHLESS
What a surprised toastmaster might say!
(12)
Universal Crossword
Jan 20, 2026
50%
IMSPEECHLESS
What a surprised toastmaster might say!
Universal Crossword · Jan 20, 2026
50%
YOUREKIDDING
What a surprised goatherd might say!
(12)
Universal Crossword
Jan 20, 2026
50%
YOUREKIDDING
What a surprised goatherd might say!
Universal Crossword · Jan 20, 2026
50%
GETOUTOFTOWN
What a surprised travel agent might say!
(12)
Universal Crossword
Jan 20, 2026
50%
GETOUTOFTOWN
What a surprised travel agent might say!
Universal Crossword · Jan 20, 2026
50%
YOUD
"___ be surprised!"
(4)
Universal Crossword
Oct 19, 2025
50%
YOUD
"___ be surprised!"
Universal Crossword · Oct 19, 2025
50%
ABACK
Taken __: surprised
(5)
LA Times Daily Crossword
Jan 21, 2025
50%
ABACK
Taken __: surprised
LA Times Daily Crossword · Jan 21, 2025
50%
OHO
Cry of surprised delight
(3)
Universal Crossword
Apr 3, 2024
50%
OHO
Cry of surprised delight
Universal Crossword · Apr 3, 2024
50%
GEE
"Color me surprised!"
(3)
Universal Crossword
Jul 23, 2023
50%
GEE
"Color me surprised!"
Universal Crossword · Jul 23, 2023
50%
AMI
"Why ___ not surprised?"
(3)
Universal Crossword
May 9, 2023
50%
AMI
"Why ___ not surprised?"
Universal Crossword · May 9, 2023
50%
GAPE
Look surprised
(4)
Universal Crossword
Aug 3, 2022
50%
GAPE
Look surprised
Universal Crossword · Aug 3, 2022
50%
INOT
"Why am ___ surprised?"
(4)
Universal Crossword
Jul 20, 2022
50%
INOT
"Why am ___ surprised?"
Universal Crossword · Jul 20, 2022
50%
ACTSO
“Don’t — surprised!”
(5)
Premier Sunday Crossword
Oct 31, 2021
50%
ACTSO
“Don’t — surprised!”
Premier Sunday Crossword · Oct 31, 2021
50%
USEDTOIT
Not surprised
(8)
LA Times Daily Crossword
Jul 3, 2021
50%
USEDTOIT
Not surprised
LA Times Daily Crossword · Jul 3, 2021
50%
JUSTLIKETHAT
65-Across, to one surprised by how quickly something happened
(12)
Universal Crossword
Jan 13, 2021
50%
JUSTLIKETHAT
65-Across, to one surprised by how quickly something happened
Universal Crossword · Jan 13, 2021
50%
FORME
Gift recipient's surprised query
(5)
LA Times Daily Crossword
Sep 30, 2020
50%
FORME
Gift recipient's surprised query
LA Times Daily Crossword · Sep 30, 2020
50%
ISAY
Brit's surprised cry
(4)
Universal Crossword
Aug 26, 2020
50%
ISAY
Brit's surprised cry
Universal Crossword · Aug 26, 2020
50%
ETTU
Caesar's surprised words
(4)
LA Times Daily Crossword
Jun 18, 2018
50%
ETTU
Caesar's surprised words
LA Times Daily Crossword · Jun 18, 2018
Clues for Universal Crossword on October 5, 2022
Don't blow it!
Crossword Clue
"The Rehearsal" network
Crossword Clue
Booze cruise setting, maybe
Crossword Clue
Sat in a wine barrel
Crossword Clue
Middle-earth monster
Crossword Clue
Having less room for dessert
Crossword Clue
TV series starring Elle Fanning as empress of Russia
Crossword Clue
Backyard beehive, e.g.
Crossword Clue
Vote in favor
Crossword Clue
Sobbed
Crossword Clue
Frequently Asked Questions
How many possible solutions does ""I'm not surprised"" have?
We found 1 exact solution and 20 total potential answers including similar clues. The most likely answer is ITFIGURES (9 letters).
What is the best answer for ""I'm not surprised""?
The best answer for ""I'm not surprised"" is ITFIGURES with 9 letters.
This answer has a 99% confidence rating based on our database of crossword solutions.
Where has ""I'm not surprised"" been used as a crossword clue?
This clue has appeared 1 time in our database.
It has been featured in Universal Crossword.
It was last seen in the Universal Crossword on October 5, 2022.